Originally published in Oregon Business magazine, May 2003
CAN SUSTAINABILITY SUSTAIN US?
By Oakley Brooks
It was in the late 1980s
that longtime logger Jim Stublefield started to feel
some deep distress about his industry. Cutting down
trees wasn't paying, and Stublefield was planting
saplings to scratch out a living instead.
Stublefield eventually decided he could log in a less-destructive
way and in 2000 opened his own timber operation in the little town of
Wolf Creek, north of Grants Pass. He's sawing and finishing logs that
have been harvested to reduce forest fire danger, taken from private
land without clear-cutting, or salvaged from the junk pile at large
sawmills. He calls this "sustainable yield" logging -- "I get no joy in
thumping big trees now." And he wants his new business to do
something rare in a resource-dependent industry: He wants it to
last. "I'm from Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, which used to have the
largest sawmill in the world. Now there are no big trees and there's
nothing but paper mills," Stublefield says. "I just want something that
will survive me, that we can keep doing forever. That's
sustainable." Used in the broadest sense, "sustainability" -- the
buzzword that's now being tossed around progressive business circles --
encompasses economic viability, human health and environmental
preservation. It's in environmental practices where Oregon
businesses lead the pack. They are pursuing several key goals: -
Don't extract any natural resources from the land faster than they can
be replenished; - Don't introduce toxins that can't be broken down
in nature; - Close the circle of production and consumption by
recycling, reusing and reclaiming materials to the greatest extent
possible. So local builders are putting up new offices with recycled
wood and paint, and installing energy-efficient windows and lights. A
major metal fabricator is reusing wastewater to cast steel. A
cooperative of Central Oregon ranchers is grazing only as many head of
cattle as the natural grasses of the high desert can support. Ruth
Rominger has been following the state's steep trajectory as vice
president of San Francisco-based U.S. Natural Step, which helps
companies implement green business practices. "There's more going on in
more sectors in Oregon than any other state," she says. business
people are doing these things in part because they make financial
sense. Already, environmental limits have wreaked havoc on Oregon
resource industries such as fishing, where stocks have been severely
depleted. Pollutants endanger human health and leave companies
vulnerable to potential liability far into the future. In coming
decades, these sorts of natural limits will ripple through the economy,
with serious consequences for companies that worsen the situation even
slightly. "The main reason for businesses to engage sustainability
is the same reason for society to embrace it," says Alan Durning,
executive director of Northwest Environment Watch in Seattle. "If
business isn't sustainable, sooner or later there is no economy."
Around the world, major corporations are realizing that a strong
environmental ethic is a matter of survival. Look no further than Ford,
which is rebuilding its massive Dearborn, Mich., auto assembly complex
using rooftop plants to filter stormwater and solar panels and fuel
cells to help power production. Oregon companies that are bringing
these ideas into the economic mainstream span numerous industries:
timber, retail, architecture, food services, event planning, law,
commercial contracting. They include Nike, Collins Pine, Norm Thompson,
Rejuvenation Hardware, Meeting Strategies Worldwide, Stoel Rives -- and
the list goes on. These Oregon firms are building a type of
stability into their business plans that may not add jobs or quick
revenue growth but is designed to pay off in the long term. They will
be better equipped to navigate the fast-approaching "era of limits," a
phrase writer Marc Reisner once used to describe the water crisis in
the arid American West. Oregonians are also developing a strong
foundation of knowledge and invention for export to places that aren't
as far along the road to a sustainable future. This is key, says
Durning. "Those regions of the world that figure out how to make a
profit from sustainability will have products, services and expertise
that are in great demand elsewhere." THE CHALLENGE FOR green
business advocates in Oregon is to show how companies can spend less
and earn more right now, before the economic system is in cataclysmic
environmental crisis. Jim Stublefield knows the problem well. His
sustainable yield garden furniture and cut lumber might be more
attractive to green consumers, but shoppers can still get conventional
goods for much less at Kmart. He's hoping that a new line of fir
flooring, marketed through a Northwest cooperative of small woodworkers
called Healthy Forests, Healthy Communities, will dig him out of debt.
"So far," he concedes, "I've proven I can go broke with the best of
them." But many local companies are demonstrating that implementing
ambitious environmental goals actually helps the bottom line. When
John Emrick, CEO of catalog retailer Norm Thompson, was planning the
company's new Hillsboro headquarters in the mid-1990s, he was looking
for ways to reduce environmental impact and save money. He directed
contractors to use recycled materials and low-toxin adhesives and
paints. Then Emrick signed off on a cutting-edge computerized heating
and air conditioning system that would conserve energy and pay for the
green architectural features within eight years. By 2000, four
years after the building was completed, the extra money was already
paid back. "That's when the financial people said, 'Now let's look
at the rest of the company,'" Emrick says. Norm Thompson is cutting
packaging use by as much as 20% by shipping all of a customer's
purchases in one box. That saves more than $300,000 a year. The company
has also saved with small nips and tucks -- it traded paper cups for
coffee mugs and saved another $10,000. Collins Pine, the subsidiary
of Portland-based wood products manufacturer Collins Companies, is
making sustainability pay off as well. New equipment at the company's
Klamath Falls hardboard and particleboard manufacturing facility now
uses mountains of sander dust, formely burned as waste, to make
particleboards at a savings of $562,000 a year. Collins has also
stopped using an onsite landfill -- waste is recycled, reused or burned
for fuel -- and it has a goal of eliminating wastewater. Teams of
Collins employees have uncovered ways to reuse steam, wood chips and
other byproducts along the production line. "The annual savings have
been in the seven-figure range," says senior vice president Wade Mosby.
SUSTAINABILITY IS ALL WELL AND GOOD, critics say, for
well-heeled companies that can afford to revamp their operations and
might even get a boost in the marketplace by highlighting their "green"
credentials. "Environmental stewardship is an important thing, but
if you can't afford it, it doesn't get done," says Paulette Pyle, with
the farm lobbying organization Oregonians for Food and Shelter. "The
'bigs' can afford it." It's true that both Norm Thompson and Collins
are large enough (at No. 29 and No. 37 on Oregon Business' 2002 list of
top private companies) to fund training, studies and new equipment
to alter their internal practices -- for instance, paying for the
services of Natural Step coordinators. But smaller operations are
successfully taking the plunge as well. Consider Chown Hardware, a
distributor based in Northwest Portland. The company sends out around
115 orders a day, but warehouse manager Rob Combs says he rarely buys
any new packaging because the company reuses all incoming boxes, saving
around $15,000 annually. Chown also sends wooden pallets and foam to
other small businesses in Northwest Oregon, lowering garbage collection
costs. Last year, Chown turned down an opportunity for a government
grant to enhance these efforts,"because it doesn't cost us anything to
recycle," says Combs. Portland's Hot Lips Pizza, with three shops
in the city, has made small investments pay off. It installed new
freezers, light bulbs, and a water heater at a cost of $3,000. With its
energy bill cut in half, the company paid back the investment in seven
months. Many local companies were taking big steps toward
sustainability before it became a buzzword. For instance, winners of
Portland's Businesses for an Environmentally Sustainable Tomorrow
(BEST) awards over the years have been companies such as Boeing, which
cut its energy consumption in half with new air compressors in the
early 1990s, and Columbia Steel Casting, which began water conservation
measures in the early 1980s and now saves $500,000 annually.
Roseburg Forest Products president Allyn Ford doesn't think changes in
efficiency -- such as Collins Pines' in Klamath Falls -- are anything
special, even though they've been grouped as part of a new
sustainability movement. "We solved our waste problems in the early
1970s," Ford says. "To say we've got a revolution on our hands, I don't
know." But what Collins is doing isn't limited to reuse and
recycling on its production lines. The company's private forestlands,
mostly in California and Pennsylvania, were the first in the U.S. to
receive certification from the international Forest Stewardship
Council, which assures that foresters are maximizing soil, water and
wildlife habitat conservation. Other Oregon companies are also
pushing the envelope. Nike has committed to phasing out polyvinyl
chloride (the leather substitute known as vinyl) because it generates a
host of harmful toxins. Norm Thompson says it will also push to stop
using vinyl and buy only cotton grown without chemical pesticides or
fertilizers. WILL LOCAL EARLY ADOPTERS of sustainability give
Oregon a leg up in the long run? Not likely, says John Ledger,
environmental policy director at Associated Oregon Industries. "It
has a benefit in how you run a company and a benefit to society," says
Ledger. "But sustainability is not going to set the state economy on
fire." Oregon's building sector, though, defies that assessment.
Over a decade or so, Portland has gone from a place with a handful of
green builders to a hub of national innovation where green building
practices are widespread. "When I go to other cities, people there
think we walk on water," says Greg Acker, an architect in Portland's
Office of Sustainable Development. Key demonstration projects in the
Portland metro area in the mid-1990s, such as North Clackamas High
School and a futuristic house sponsored by Portland General Electric,
showed that features such as nontoxic building materials and
energy-saving lighting systems designed to respond to daylight could be
installed without vast expense. "Once builders realized that green
building was not about a political agenda but that it made sense, it
took off," says Nathan Good, a former member of PGE's green building
team and now an architect with CH2M Hill. Then, in 2000, a new
national system for rating buildings, Leadership in Energy and
Environmental Design (LEED), was launched by the U.S. Green Building
Council. (The council's president, Christine Ervin, is based in
Portland). Builders apply to have their projects rated on everything
from energy-efficient appliances to reused materials and nontoxic
paint. LEED gives local contractors something concrete to shoot for.
Portland now has the most LEED buildings per capita of any city in the
nation, and Oregon has the first LEED-certified winery building at
Sokol-Blosser's Dundee vineyards. And the state capitol has added
rooftop solar panels, making it a beacon for alternative energy
advocates. "Green building has proved to be an alternative much
faster than I would have expected," says Cindy Catto of Associated
General Contractors in Oregon. "My contractors find that having the
[LEED expertise] arrow in their quiver helps distinguish them. Now,
medium and large contractors are focusing on what it takes to be LEED
certified." Tax credits and grants from the city of Portland, as
well as a PGE-state housing department low-interest loan program, also
support the market for green building. And a growing network of
suppliers has emerged to service these new projects -- from PPG
Industries' plant in Salem, which manufactures high-performance
windows, to Stormwater Management, which has built new filters to
purify runoff before it heads to local streams and rivers. These
support companies, Good says, could be "one of the great economic
producers in the state." A GROWING CONSUMER MARKET has helped
boost green industries in Oregon. Buyers' willingness to pay more
for goods that are grown without pesticides, chemical fertilizers or
hormones has driven the success of companies as diverse as Oregon
Country Beef, a cooperative of 40 Central and Eastern Oregon ranches
raising natural-fed cattle, and Emerald Valley Kitchen in Eugene, which
makes hummus and salsa dips with pesticide-free ingredients.
Customer interest declines when they can't clearly see the
environmental effects of their purchases. Collins' Wade Mosby says
the public has yet to show a great preference for more expensive wood
products bearing the Forest Stewardship Council certification label,
but consumers and wholesalers will buy environmentally sensitive wood
when the price matches that on conventional items. Home Depot and
Lowe's have agreed to give this sort of preference to lumber from
certified forests. That's attracted the attention of sustainability
skeptics such as Roseburg Forest Products' Ford, who says he's working
with the Stewardship Council to have more of his company's timberland
certified. Other Northwest forest products companies such as
Weyerhaeuser and Hampton Affiliates have joined a less stringent
industry-sponsored certification process called the Sustainable
Forestry Initiative. Consumers' desire for more green products
ultimately presents a dilemma. Should a company do just the bare
minimum to appear green and attract more customers, without adding to
its costs? This is "greenwashing," a buzzword among corporate watchdog
groups that has mirrored the spread of "sustainability." Martin
Goebel, executive director of the Portland-based nonprofit Sustainable
Northwest, isn't worried: "This is a global imperative; if a company is
embracing this stuff at any level it's good." Norm Thompson's John
Emrick thinks he has a simple way to let consumers decide these issues.
He plans to eventually allow customers to "drill down" from any food,
craft or piece of clothing that's featured in the company's online
catalog, all the way back to the item's maker. "That challenges the
merchants, " says Emrick. "We're going to tell people exactly where
this came from." COMPANIES AND COUNTRIES are looking to Oregon's
pioneering expertise as they grow their own environmental practices.
For example, Team Oregon, a network of green consultants, architects
and engineers, helped craft a national sustainability framework for
Taiwan and is advising Chinese cities on waterway cleanup. And Oregon
high-tech types are involved in discussions with computer companies
about a nationwide recycling program for PCs and printers.
"Seventy-five percent of computers are sitting in storage," says Wayne
Rifer, a consultant in Cedar Mills. "If it's a newer model, it can be
reused. If it's older, there's recycling value in the materials."
Rifer says one result of the program will be that computer makers will
begin designing new machines so they can be easily deconstructed and
the components incorporated into new products. Nike is exploring
this sort of product design. Instead of grinding down used sneakers to
make basketball courts and turf fields in the future, the company will
take them back and build new sneakers out of the materials from the
worn-out shoes. Futurists such as William McDonough and Michael
Braungart, authors of the recent book Cradle to Cradle: Remaking the
Way We Make Things, say this idea of "product take-back" is the most
economical and environmentally responsible way to do business. It puts
companies in a position to take advantage of a new sort of world
marketplace, where resources are scarce and there's great value in
manufactured items returning to the producer. It's a trend that will
affect everything from cars to grocery bags. And companies across
Oregon are demonstrating that aligning with this emerging environmental
ethic can be a financial asset right now. It's the sort of creative
thinking that has helped push Oregon toward economic and ecological
stability in the past. And will again in the future.
If you have comments about any articles you've read in Oregon Business magazine, e-mail us
at
feedback@oregonbusiness.com.
Copyright 2003 Oregon Business magazine
|